On Saturday morning, Eileen sent a message saying the gathering would probably last only half an hour. There were other things Leon might prefer to do with his afternoon. He read it while standing over the toaster, with a plate in one hand. The household asked whether he wanted the bread kept warm. “Please.” He drafted a reply about how much he was looking forward to hearing her, then erased it. That seemed to put the afternoon’s success into her mouth before she had opened it. He wrote, “I’m still coming. Would you like me to wait outside?” Her answer arrived after he had finished eating. “No. Come in and get yourself a seat.”

The former school stood behind a low fence threaded with the dead stalks of summer beans. Most of the building had become apartments, but three ground-floor classrooms remained available for shared use. Through one window Leon saw a woman rolling a ball of clay between her palms. Through another, someone was lying on a mat with a folded towel over their eyes. He checked the address again, then found a paper arrow taped below the entrance panel. SINGING, it said. One corner had come loose in the damp. He pressed it down as he passed, and by the time the door opened it had lifted again.

Inside the classroom, the chairs faced a piano-shaped cabinet with no keyboard. There were perhaps twenty seats, several occupied by coats. A man near the door offered Leon tea and pointed out water, cups, and a plate of sliced pears. The food had arrived with the building’s afternoon supplies; someone had arranged the pears in overlapping circles, then abandoned the pattern halfway through. Leon chose a chair in the second row. From there he could see the singers without being the nearest person to them. He put his scarf in his pocket rather than on the adjoining seat. Eileen had invited him, not given him a place to reserve.

She stood by the windows with a folder open against her chest. Her blouse was dark blue, and she wore a small silver pin shaped like a leaf. He had seen the pin before, on the cardigan, but had never understood it as something she had chosen separately. She noticed him and lifted two fingers from the folder. He lifted his hand. For a moment he thought she might come over. Instead she turned to a woman beside her and said something that made them both look down at the music. Leon accepted this without taking out his phone to occupy himself. Near the cabinet, a boy was carefully separating two nested paper cups.

The man serving tea joined two singers at the wall panel. They had arranged for distant relatives to listen, but their proposed setting would also have sent a recording afterward to everyone invited. One woman said they had listed it as a rehearsal so it would save automatically. The panel replied in the same low voice it had used to explain the room’s lights: rehearsal capture covered the participants who had agreed, not guests or additional singers. The gathering could still be shared live. For a recording, it could leave out anyone who declined. “Live is fine,” the man said after a pause. He returned to pouring tea. Nothing else was withdrawn.

Eileen came over before they began. “I haven’t decided,” she said. Leon knew which decision she meant. He moved his knees aside, though she had not asked to sit. “All right.” She glanced toward the windows. “Marian says we can all sing that bit. We tried it on Wednesday.” He nearly asked which version sounded better. Instead he said, “Do you need to tell her now?” Eileen shook her head. “She said I can nod.” There was a loose thread at the edge of her folder. She wound it around a fingernail, then let it go. “It’s ridiculous, isn’t it?” “Which part?” he asked. She gave him a brief, unwilling smile. “That’s a very careful answer.”

They began with a song Leon recognized only after the second line. His mother had sung it while doing things that prevented her from finishing: rinsing clothes, answering the door, looking for a lid. Here the tune continued beyond the point where his memory stopped. The accompaniment came from the cabinet, a plain piano sound with something softer beneath it. When the singers lengthened a phrase, it lengthened with them. A woman in the back row came in early, stopped, and rejoined without anyone turning. Leon had expected to feel relieved on their behalf when they got through a difficult passage. Instead he found himself listening for the next one.

Before the third song, Eileen moved her folder from one hand to the other. Marian, who stood at the end of the row, looked toward her without raising her eyebrows or smiling encouragement. Eileen gave a small nod. Leon could not tell what it meant until the short passage arrived and three voices entered together. He heard hers among them, lower than he had imagined, with a roughness at the start of one word. Then the others joined. It was not possible to know, from hearing it, that anything had been relinquished. He watched Eileen turn the page and missed the next line.

Afterward, the chairs scraped and the room became awkward in the ordinary way of gatherings that had finished their stated purpose. People did not know whether to leave or eat another piece of fruit. Leon stayed seated until Eileen reached him. “I didn’t do it,” she said. He stood. “No.” Her face tightened, and he wished he had found a less bare word. “I heard you in the three.” “That wasn’t the same.” “I know.” He did not know much about the difference, but he knew she was entitled to one. Behind her, Marian was retrieving a dropped pencil from under the cabinet with the toe of her shoe.

Eileen sat on the chair beside his, and Leon sat again. “Please don’t say there’s always next time.” “I wasn’t going to.” He had been, though not quite yet. She looked at him, and he admitted it. Her laugh was small but unmistakable. They listened while a woman explained to her husband that the cabinet had not rescued them when they lost their place; it had waited because Marian had asked it to. “I liked the first song,” Leon said. He told Eileen about his mother and the unfinished verses. She asked which verse he remembered. He tried to say the words, discovered he could only find them with the tune, and stopped after a few embarrassed notes. Eileen did not finish it for him.

They helped return their own cups, leaving the chairs to the people who knew where they belonged. Outside, the afternoon had cooled. Eileen put on her green coat and struggled briefly with a sleeve caught around her watch. Leon kept his hands at his sides until she freed it. They walked toward the bus stop past the classroom where the clay worker was now washing a board. “I’m glad you came,” Eileen said. “I’m not glad about all of it.” He understood that better than he had understood the music. At the shelter, she took a folded shopping bag from her pocket and smoothed it over her knee.

“I opened the carton again,” she said. Leon looked at her. “From work. After we went back.” A bus passed without stopping, carrying the warm smell of wet coats through its open upper vent. She said his packing had been careful; the cup was still wrapped in a supplier’s wall calendar. He remembered folding it around the handle. “There’s an envelope under the cardboard at the bottom. Your writing. My name.” He waited, trying to recover the last week in the order it had actually happened. “I don’t remember,” he said. Eileen tucked the shopping bag away. “I haven’t opened it. Would you be there when I do?”

✳